News · July 16, 2020
EU court ends Privacy Shield, keeps contract clauses for data transfers
The Court of Justice of the EU has struck down the EU-US Privacy Shield but left standard contractual clauses in place under stricter conditions. Marketing and analytics tools that send EU user data to the US are directly affected.
What happened
- In its judgment in case C-311/18, the Court of Justice of the EU ruled that the Commission's Privacy Shield adequacy decision 2016/1250 is invalid, according to the text published on EUR-Lex.
- The court found nothing affecting the validity of the Commission's standard contractual clauses decision, but said transfers under those clauses must give protection essentially equivalent to EU law, taking into account access by public authorities in the destination country.
- Where such protection cannot be ensured, supervisory authorities must suspend or prohibit the transfer if the controller has not already done so, the judgment says.
- TechCrunch reported that more than 5,300 companies had used Privacy Shield and that the European Commission said data could continue to flow under standard contractual clauses and binding corporate rules.
Why it matters
Most ad, analytics and attribution stacks used by apps with EU users rely on US-based vendors. Teams should list which tools receive EU personal data and on what legal basis, since many relied on Privacy Shield until today.
This is a legal question first, so involve counsel. From the engineering side, it helps to know exactly which events and identifiers each SDK sends, and which could be reduced, aggregated or kept in the EU if needed.
Sources
- EUR-Lex (Court of Justice of the EU): Data Protection Commissioner v Facebook Ireland Limited and Maximillian Schrems, Case C-311/18
- TechCrunch: Europe's top court strikes down flagship EU-US data transfer mechanism
This post is CMM’s own summary and commentary on publicly reported news. Facts are attributed to the sources linked above; please read them for full details. CMM is not affiliated with these publishers or with the companies mentioned, and trademarks belong to their owners. Prepared with AI assistance. Corrections or requests: [email protected]. See our editorial policy.
Want help with this?
Tell us what you need, and we will suggest the right team model on a short call.
Talk to us