Book a call

News · July 8, 2025

Appeals court vacates the FTC click-to-cancel rule days before enforcement

// ios.news :: 2025

The US Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit has vacated the FTC's amended Negative Option Rule, known as click-to-cancel, shortly before full enforcement was due to begin. The decision rests on rulemaking procedure, and the laws behind most FTC subscription cases remain in place.

What happened

  • In its July 8 judgment in Custom Communications, Inc. v. Federal Trade Commission, the Eighth Circuit granted the petitions for review and vacated the rule, according to the court's judgment.
  • Latham & Watkins explains that the court found the FTC should have prepared a preliminary regulatory analysis, which is required when a rule's annual economic effect is estimated at $100 million or more, after an administrative law judge found the compliance burden would exceed that level. The court treated the error as prejudicial and did not rule on the substantive challenges.
  • Per Latham & Watkins, the FTC had been set to begin full enforcement of the rule on July 14, 2025.
  • Mayer Brown notes that ROSCA, Section 5 of the FTC Act, the original 1973 Negative Option Rule and state automatic renewal laws still apply, citing California's amended law in effect from July 1, 2025.

Why it matters

For subscription teams, the practical change is smaller than the headline suggests. The FTC's cases against subscription sellers have mostly relied on ROSCA and the FTC Act, which already require clear disclosure, express consent and a simple way to cancel, and several states have their own auto-renewal laws with detailed rules.

We suggest keeping the improvements made in preparation for the rule rather than rolling them back. Clear paywalls and easy cancellation also tend to reduce refunds, chargebacks and store complaints, which matter for revenue whatever happens to the rule. This is a practical view, not legal advice.

Sources

This post is CMM’s own summary and commentary on publicly reported news. Facts are attributed to the sources linked above; please read them for full details. CMM is not affiliated with these publishers or with the companies mentioned, and trademarks belong to their owners. Prepared with AI assistance. Corrections or requests: [email protected]. See our editorial policy.

Want help with this?

Tell us what you need, and we will suggest the right team model on a short call.

Talk to us