Book a call

News · September 2, 2020

ABCmouse to pay $10 million to settle FTC case over auto-renewing plans

// ios.news :: 2020

The company behind the children's learning service ABCmouse has agreed to a $10 million settlement with the FTC over how it sold and renewed memberships. The order terms read like a template for what an annual plan and a free trial should disclose.

What happened

  • Age of Learning, which runs ABCmouse, will pay $10 million under a proposed stipulated order filed in the US District Court for the Central District of California, the FTC announced on September 2. The order takes legal force once the judge approves and signs it.
  • The FTC alleges that from 2015 until at least 2018 the company did not adequately disclose that its discounted 12-month plans and its paid extensions of a 30-day free trial renewed automatically and indefinitely.
  • The FTC also alleges that cancellation was difficult despite promises of easy cancellation. Robinson & Cole, writing in its Data Privacy + Security Insider, notes that company records reportedly showed hundreds of thousands of users who tried to cancel between 2015 and 2018 and stayed subscribed.
  • According to the FTC, the proposed order bars calling an offer free or a trial when users must act to avoid charges, and requires the company to explain key renewal terms before collecting billing details, get informed consent before automatic billing and provide a simple way to cancel.

Why it matters

Annual plans are the most valuable product for many subscription apps, and this case shows where they are most exposed: the renewal after the first year. If the paywall promotes a discounted first year, the renewal price and the fact that it will renew should be visible on the same screen, not only in the terms of use. The same applies to a trial that converts into a paid plan.

For apps sold through the App Store or Google Play, the store handles billing and cancellation, but the paywall copy is still the developer's. We suggest checking that words such as free, trial and easy cancellation are accurate for every plan, and that web checkouts outside the stores meet at least the same standard. This is a practical view, not legal advice.

Sources

This post is CMM’s own summary and commentary on publicly reported news. Facts are attributed to the sources linked above; please read them for full details. CMM is not affiliated with these publishers or with the companies mentioned, and trademarks belong to their owners. Prepared with AI assistance. Corrections or requests: [email protected]. See our editorial policy.

Want help with this?

Tell us what you need, and we will suggest the right team model on a short call.

Talk to us