News · June 17, 2024
DOJ and FTC take Adobe to court over its early termination fee
The Justice Department, acting on an FTC referral, has sued Adobe over how it discloses the early termination fee on its most popular subscription plan and how customers cancel. Any app selling annual plans billed monthly should read the allegations closely.
What happened
- According to the FTC's June 17 press release, the Department of Justice filed the complaint in the US District Court for the Northern District of California against Adobe and two of its executives, alleging violations of ROSCA. The Commission voted 3-0 to refer it; the FTC notes the court will decide the case.
- The FTC alleges Adobe pre-selected its annual paid monthly plan and showed the monthly price prominently, while the fee for cancelling in the first year, equal to 50 percent of the remaining monthly payments, appeared in small print or behind hover icons.
- The FTC also alleges that cancelling online required many pages, that support staff resisted or delayed cancellation requests, and that some customers who thought they had cancelled were still charged.
- PYMNTS reports that Adobe said it would contest the claims in court and that it is transparent about its terms and offers a simple cancellation process.
Why it matters
Annual plans billed monthly are attractive because they combine a low monthly price with a yearly commitment. The allegations show the risk: if the commitment and the exit fee are not as visible as the monthly price, users may feel misled when they try to leave. A pre-selected plan makes that risk larger.
If you sell this type of plan on the web, we suggest stating the commitment and any exit fee next to the price, not in a tooltip, and showing the exact fee in the cancellation flow before the user confirms. Consider whether a plain monthly plan or a prepaid annual plan would be easier to explain. This is a practical view, not legal advice.
Sources
- FTC press release: FTC Takes Action Against Adobe and Executives for Hiding Fees, Preventing Consumers from Easily Cancelling Software Subscriptions
- PYMNTS: FTC Alleges Adobe Deters Subscription Cancellations, Hides Early Termination Fee
This post is CMM’s own summary and commentary on publicly reported news. Facts are attributed to the sources linked above; please read them for full details. CMM is not affiliated with these publishers or with the companies mentioned, and trademarks belong to their owners. Prepared with AI assistance. Corrections or requests: [email protected]. See our editorial policy.
Want help with this?
Tell us what you need, and we will suggest the right team model on a short call.
Talk to us