News · December 18, 2025
Instacart to refund $60 million in FTC case over trials and fee claims
Instacart has agreed to pay $60 million in consumer refunds to settle FTC allegations about its delivery-fee advertising, its satisfaction guarantee and the free trial of its Instacart+ membership. The refunds go to people charged for the membership without proper consent.
What happened
- According to the FTC's December 18 press release, a proposed stipulated order was filed in the US District Court for the Northern District of California, with the Commission voting 2-0. The order takes effect once the judge approves and signs it.
- The FTC alleges that Instacart+ trial sign-ups did not adequately disclose that members would be charged when the trial ended or the restrictive refund policy, and that hundreds of thousands of consumers were charged without express informed consent.
- The FTC also alleges that free delivery claims left out a mandatory service fee of up to 15 percent of the order, and that a full satisfaction guarantee usually produced only credit, with the refund option hidden in the self-service menu.
- TechCrunch reports that Instacart denied any wrongdoing and described the FTC's inquiry as flawed. Under the order, per the FTC, Instacart must clearly disclose terms and obtain express informed consent for subscriptions that charge unless the user opts out.
Why it matters
Free trials that convert to paid memberships remain one of the most common subjects of FTC subscription cases. The pattern regulators look for is simple: was the user told, at sign-up, that a charge would follow and when, and did the user agree to that charge rather than only to the trial?
We suggest showing the first charge date and amount on the trial screen, sending a reminder before the trial converts, and making the refund policy easy to find. The same discipline applies to fee claims in ads: if a benefit is called free, any mandatory fee should be shown with it. This is a practical view, not legal advice.
Sources
- FTC press release: Instacart to Pay $60 Million in Consumer Refunds to Settle FTC Lawsuit Over Allegations it Engaged in Deceptive Tactics
- TechCrunch: Instacart to pay $60M to settle FTC claims it deceived consumers
This post is CMM’s own summary and commentary on publicly reported news. Facts are attributed to the sources linked above; please read them for full details. CMM is not affiliated with these publishers or with the companies mentioned, and trademarks belong to their owners. Prepared with AI assistance. Corrections or requests: [email protected]. See our editorial policy.
Want help with this?
Tell us what you need, and we will suggest the right team model on a short call.
Talk to us